There are songs that get under your skin and the kind that move through you so completely that they become part of your bloodstream. For me, Oceans (Where Feet May Fail) by Hillsong Worship was one of those songs. For years, it was my anthem, my lifeline, my “Yes, Lord, I’ll go where you lead me” soundtrack.
It was the song I sang when I felt close to God, when I didn’t feel close to God, and when I was desperate to feel close again. I’d play it while working, in the shower, before bed. I’d cry through it, hands out, convinced that if I just surrendered a little bit more, trusted a little bit harder, I’d finally feel what everyone else seemed to feel - certainty, closeness, peace.
Now, it’s one of the most triggering songs I know.
The moment those opening notes play (I know you know it too), the soft build, that haunting melody, my stomach drops. My body tenses. I go straight back to being that woman in her twenties, desperate for divine direction, singing, “Spirit, lead me where my trust is without borders.”
And look, I get it. It’s beautiful. The writing, the vocals, the swell of emotion that makes you feel like you could walk on water yourself. It’s moving, powerful, hypnotic. But that’s the problem. It’s too powerful. Because in the hands of a high-control system, beauty becomes a weapon.
The seductive power of surrender
Worship music like Oceans isn’t just music, it’s theology set to melody. It’s a sermon you sing, a belief you internalise.
The song’s central idea is total surrender. No limits. No questions. No borders. Trust God completely. Go where He leads. Step out of the boat, even if you can’t see the path.
It sounds poetic and for many people, it probably is. But in high-control religious systems, this kind of messaging lands differently. It’s not just a call to trust, it’s a call to erasure. Because in those systems, “trust” means obedience. “Faith” means silence. “Surrender” means submission to authority, even when it hurts.
So when I sang “Spirit lead me where my trust is without borders,” what I was really saying was: I’ll silence my instincts. I’ll override my boundaries. I’ll make myself small enough to fit your will.
I didn’t know it then, but I was emotionally manipulating myself.
And the song made it easy.
The performance of faith
Every time I sang Oceans in worship service (or even watching it online), I could feel and see the room shift. The lights would dim. The band would soften. The lyrics would hit the bridge, “Take me deeper than my feet could ever wander” and the congregation would erupt into that familiar blend of tears, swaying, and open palms.
It was transcendent. It was intoxicating. And it was entirely manufactured.
Worship leaders are taught how to build an emotional arc, when to drop the keys, when to hold the note, when to repeat the bridge until the crowd breaks. It’s not all manipulative by design, but it’s strategic. The goal isn’t just to play music; it’s to lead people into an emotional experience that looks like connection to God.
And if you’ve ever been desperate for belonging or meaning, that moment feels holy. You believe something sacred is happening because you feel it happening.
That’s what makes it so dangerous. Emotional manipulation isn’t always loud or cruel. Sometimes it’s wrapped in piano chords and poetic lyrics that make you cry.
When “trust” becomes trauma
I think part of why this song hits me so hard now is because it was the title track on the soundtrack to my self-abandonment. I used it to convince myself that discomfort was holy. That doubt was sin. That every instinct I had to say no was a lack of faith.
The church loved to preach about Peter walking on water and about the faith it took to step out of the boat. But what they didn’t tell us was that blind trust isn’t faith. It’s conditioning.
I stepped out of that boat over and over again.
Into relationships that erased me.
Into ministries that exploited me.
Into belief systems that blamed me.
And every time I started to drown, I told myself it was because I wasn’t trusting enough. I just needed more faith. More surrender. More of whatever invisible standard God (or more accurately, the men who claimed to speak for Him) required.
The secular glow-up
Part of what makes Oceans such a mind-bending experience for those of us who’ve left is how deeply it’s infiltrated mainstream culture. It’s not just in churches, it’s in Instagram reels, cafés, Spotify playlists, even weddings. You can hear it without realising it’s worship music.
For most people, it’s just a pretty song about faith and courage. For those of us who lived inside that system, it’s a visceral reminder of what we gave up to be “faithful.”
That’s what’s so wild about Hillsong’s global reach. They managed to blur the line between worship and pop, between devotion and performance. It’s why so many of their songs feel familiar even if you’ve never set foot in a church because they were engineered to.
There’s actually a term for it: crossover worship, which is the intentional production of worship songs that sound like mainstream pop, designed to reach both Christian and secular audiences. And it worked. Hillsong mastered it.
But when art is built on control, even beauty becomes a recruitment tool.
The grief underneath the music
I can’t separate Oceans from the person I was when I loved it. The girl who believed God was testing her faith every time life got hard. The woman who thought “being used by God” meant saying yes to everything, even when it broke her.
When I hear that familiar intro, it feels like standing at the grave of an old version of myself, someone I loved and pitied at the same time. She was trying so hard to be good. To be faithful. To be enough.
When I hear that song in public now, at a café, in a store, on someone’s playlist - I freeze. My heart races. My body remembers every time I begged God to show me where to step next. Every time I mistook fear for faith. Every time I called coercion “calling.”
Grief isn’t always about what’s gone. Sometimes it’s about what we lost in ourselves trying to be loved by something that never loved us back.
Healing means hearing differently
I don’t listen to Oceans anymore. I can’t. Maybe one day that will change, but for now, it’s okay that it’s off-limits.
Healing doesn’t mean forcing yourself to re-engage with the things that broke you. It means learning to hear your own voice underneath all the noise.
I used to think faith was about silencing fear. Now I think healing is about listening to it. Because fear is just your body trying to keep you safe, something the church trained us to override in the name of obedience.
When I catch myself humming that melody (and I still do, sometimes, because it’s ingrained), I try not to shame myself for it. Instead, I remember that my brain is doing what it was trained to do. And I remind myself: You don’t have to drown to prove you can trust.
When have you mistaken self-abandonment for faith, trust, or love?
Looking for more?
I offer therapy for those holding religious trauma, queer folk, and cult survivors in person at my Goulburn, NSW location and online Australia & New Zealand wide. Reach out here.
I also host a podcast called Beyond the Surface, where I get to chat to the most wonderful humans about their own stories of religious trauma, faith deconstruction and leaving a cult. Its available on all major podcast platforms.
I am also a co-founder of The Religious Trauma Collective (Aus/NZ), a space where you can find support, resources and community.
For a one stop shop for me and my work head here → Anchored Counselling Services



The more I read your story, the more I feel connected to my own experience. This song is at the top of the list of songs I no longer can passively engage with because of the use it had in my own self abandonment. I remember standing in the ocean, face toward the waves, singing this perseveratively trying to align my soul with my container of faith. It felt intentional and in that way magical though now I see how it was shrouded in dissociation too. I try to remember now that the person I was then was still trying to find her way through life with radical intentionality and I can appreciate that about her. I'm also really grateful that her intentionality eventually led me to grow into not needing that faith container to determine for me what the spirit leading me should dictate. Thanks for reminding me.