There’s a particular kind of irony that comes with growing up in purity culture and then later becoming someone who talks publicly about sex, pleasure, queerness and desire without flinching. Not because I’m trying to shock anyone, I’m honestly too tired for that but because for a long time my body was treated like a problem to manage rather than a place to live.
I was taught, explicitly and implicitly, that desire was dangerous. That curiosity needed guarding. That pleasure was something you earned later, if you behaved well enough now (and only if your very-godly husband was gracious enough to care about your pleasure at all). And that the body, especially a queer body was untrustworthy. Something to discipline and something to keep quiet.
So yes, there’s irony in the fact that I now talk about sex with nuance, humour, and actual affection. There’s irony in the fact that I read spicy books and can name the tropes that make my nervous system exhale. There’s irony in the fact that pleasure, which was once framed as the enemy of holiness, has become one of the places where healing actually happens.
But maybe irony isn’t the right word.
Maybe this was always where it was heading.
Because purity culture didn’t fail me because I wanted sex. It failed me because it taught me to distrust myself.
Purity culture wasn’t just about who you slept with or when. It was about shaping an internal world where desire had to be justified, monitored, spiritualised, or suppressed. It trained bodies into compliance long before it ever needed to enforce behaviour. And once those rules move inside you, they don’t magically disappear when you leave the system.
They linger. Sometimes for years or decades.
They show up as disconnection from sensation. Experiencing pain during sex. As overthinking arousal. As a reflex to perform instead of feel. As a strange mixture of longing and shame that makes it hard to know what you actually want versus what you think you’re allowed to want.
For many of us, especially those who are queer, or grew up in high-control faith environments, pleasure didn’t feel like freedom. It felt like risk.
And that changes how you relate to your body long after you’ve stopped believing the theology.
The Body Was Never the Problem
One of the most enduring lies of purity culture is that it frames the body as the site of failure. If you struggle, it’s because you’re weak. If you desire, it’s because you’re undisciplined. If you feel aroused, attached, curious, hungry; well, that’s evidence of your fallen nature.
But that framing conveniently ignores something essential: bodies respond to safety, not sermons.
When you grow up in an environment where your worth is conditional, your nervous system adapts. Hypervigilance becomes normal. Self-monitoring becomes automatic. You learn to scan yourself for risk before anyone else has to. And eventually, you don’t need rules anymore because your body enforces them for you.
This is why so many people leave religious systems and still feel uneasy with pleasure. Why sex can feel performative instead of present. Why desire can spark guilt even when there’s nothing morally wrong happening. Why rest, softness, and indulgence can feel undeserved.
It’s not because you’re broken.
It’s because your body learned that safety depended on restraint.
From a trauma perspective, this makes perfect sense. High-control environments prioritise obedience over attunement. They reward dissociation. They spiritualise self-abandonment. And they often praise people most when they override their own instincts “for the greater good.”
So of course pleasure feels complicated later.
Pleasure requires presence. It requires inhabiting your body without apology. It asks you to trust sensation, impulse, and desire; the very things you were taught to mistrust.
Recovery, then, isn’t about suddenly becoming confident or sexually liberated or performing some reclaimed version of freedom. It’s about slowly, gently, relearning that your body is not the enemy.
And sometimes, that relearning doesn’t start in the bedroom.
Sometimes it starts in books.
Desire Finds a Way (Even When You Try to Kill It)
Here’s the thing purity culture never quite accounted for: desire doesn’t disappear just because it’s forbidden. It adapts.
For many of us, desire went underground. It found expression in imagination, fantasy, longing, and story. It lived in the spaces where no one was watching. Where there was no altar call waiting. Where no one could correct you for wanting the wrong thing.
This is where spicy books quietly enter the conversation and not as a guilty pleasure, but as a coping strategy, a rehearsal space, a place where wanting wasn’t punished.
And I want to say this clearly, without flinching: there is nothing inherently wrong or immature or damaged about finding comfort, curiosity, or even healing in erotic fiction. I fucking love reading it!!
For people recovering from purity culture, high-control religion, or sexual shame, fiction can offer something real life didn’t: consent-based desire, agency, power that isn’t immediately punished, and bodies that are allowed to want without moral consequence.
It’s not an accident that so many of the tropes people gravitate toward are about safety, choice, and re-authoring power.
Yes, sometimes that looks like praise degradation kinks. Sometimes it looks like chosen and consensual power exchange like Dom/Sub or BDSM. Sometimes it looks like reclaiming dominance or softness through textures, food, or other fun things. Sometimes it looks like religious trauma-coded spice; like ex-pastors, fallen leaders, deconstruction narratives wrapped in desire and repair.
And no, engaging with those tropes doesn’t mean you want those dynamics in real life. Fantasy is not a confession. Desire is not a contract. We read and engage in fictional content of other genres everyday - and I don’t see anyone thinking they are a real life Avenger, Avatar or can replicate Narnia
Fiction gives us a place to explore sensation without consequence, to feel into desire without having to justify it, and to practise agency in worlds where our bodies were once policed.
That matters.
Because when your early experiences of sexuality were shaped by fear, fiction can become one of the first places where pleasure feels safe enough to exist.
The Power of Language
One of the quieter violences of purity culture was linguistic. Certain words weren’t just discouraged, they were treated as corrupting. Saying them was framed as dangerous. Thinking them was suspect. Hearing them out loud could apparently undo your moral character in real time.
Words like horny. Masturbation. Orgasm. Slang words for body parts like, pussy, tits, cock all spoken in hushed tones or not at all. Kinks. Names for sex acts or positions that didn’t fit neatly into heterosexual, married, procreative boxes. Even neutral anatomical language was often policed, but anything that sounded embodied, casual, or pleasurable was outright forbidden.
And that matters, because language shapes permission.
When you aren’t allowed the words, you aren’t allowed the experiences they point to or at least not honestly. Desire becomes something you feel in fragments, without vocabulary. Sensation without language is easier to shame, easier to control, easier to spiritualise away.
So of course reclaiming desire often starts with reclaiming words.
Saying horny without flinching.
Saying masturbation without apologising.
Saying orgasm without attaching a moral disclaimer.
Naming body parts the way people actually talk about them in consensual, adult spaces, not as crude objects, not as sacred relics, but as parts of a living, feeling body.
There is nothing inherently violent about these words. Nothing immoral about naming pleasure plainly. Words don’t corrupt but silence absolutely does.
For many of us, learning to say these things out loud is part of re-entering our bodies. It’s a way of undoing the reflex that says desire must be hidden to be safe. It’s a refusal to let shame be the loudest voice in the room.
Language is power. And choosing our words, especially the ones we were told never to say is one of the ways desire finds its way back home.
Pleasure Is Not Rebellion - It’s Repair
There’s a narrative I see floating around sometimes that reclaiming pleasure is about sticking it to the church. About being edgy. About swinging wildly in the opposite direction just to prove a point.
And sure, sometimes there’s a little “fuck you” energy involved. That’s allowed and I’m definitely down with that.
But for most people I work with pleasure hasn’t been about rebellion. It’s been about repair.
It’s been about learning to feel again without self-surveillance. About letting desire arise without immediately interrogating it. About being present in the body without bracing for punishment.
Pleasure, in this context, isn’t just sexual. It’s embodied. It’s sensory. It’s relational. It’s the ability to say “this feels good” without needing a reason.
And yes, sex can be part of that. Reading spicy books can be part of that. Laughing about the tropes you love can be part of that (hello age gap, billionaire romance & religious trauma coded).
Because pleasure isn’t shallow. It’s regulating. It’s connective. It reminds the nervous system that the body can be a source of safety, not just risk.
This is especially important for people whose faith taught them that suffering was holy and desire was suspect. When pain is spiritualised, pleasure becomes threatening. And unlearning that takes time.
There’s grief here too. Grief for the years spent disconnected. Grief for the curiosity that had to be suppressed. Grief for the body you didn’t get to inhabit freely.
Reclaiming pleasure doesn’t erase that grief. It sits alongside it. Sometimes awkwardly. Sometimes tenderly. Sometimes with humour because honestly, if we can’t laugh at the absurdity of it all, we’ll drown.
Naming the Things We Were Told Not to Name
One of the most healing things about recovery and one of the most confronting is learning to speak plainly.
To name desire without spiritualising it.
To name kinks without pathologising them.
To name fantasy without assuming it reveals some deep moral truth.
Purity culture thrives on vagueness. On euphemism. On keeping things just unclear enough that shame can fill in the gaps. Naming things disrupts that.
When you can say, “I like this trope,” or “this dynamic makes me feel safe,” or “this story helped me reconnect with my body,” or simply “that was hot as fuck” you take power back from the narratives that told you wanting was dangerous.
Normalising desire doesn’t mean endorsing harm. It means trusting adults to engage with fantasy, fiction, and pleasure thoughtfully and consenually. It means recognising that curiosity is not corruption.
And it means understanding that for many people recovering from religious trauma, spice isn’t about excess. It’s about choice.
Choice that was once denied.
Choice that was once monitored.
Choice that is now being practised gently, imperfectly, humanly.
I’m Not Interested in Being Pure, I’m Interested in Being Here
I don’t want to be pure. I want to be present.
I want to live in a body that feels like mine. To experience desire without collapsing into shame. To read stories that make me feel alive without needing to justify them as educational or therapeutic.
I want pleasure that is grounded, chosen, and embodied; not performative freedom, not reactionary rebellion, not another set of rules to live up to.
And I want us to be able to talk about this without whispering. Because purity culture took enough from us already. It doesn’t get to dictate how we heal.
You are not broken for wanting.
You are not shallow for enjoying.
You are not sinful for feeling at home in your body.
You are human. And that was never the problem.
What desires are you still explaining away instead of simply allowing to exist?
Looking for more?
I offer therapy for those holding religious trauma, queer folk, and cult survivors in person at my Goulburn, NSW location and online Australia & New Zealand wide. Reach out here.
I also host a podcast called Beyond the Surface, where I get to chat to the most wonderful humans about their own stories of religious trauma, faith deconstruction and leaving a cult. Its available on all major podcast platforms.
I am also a co-founder of The Religious Trauma Collective (Aus/NZ), a space where you can find support, resources and community.
For a one stop shop for me and my work head here → Anchored Counselling Services



This piece lands for me as both personal and structural truth. What purity culture disrupted wasn’t just sexual ethics, but self-trust—training bodies to be managed rather than inhabited. I appreciate how you frame pleasure not as rebellion but as repair, and how language, story, and imagination become places where safety can return before the body is ready to follow. There is a form of righteousness that doesn’t require purity or self-erasure, and many of us have been circling back to that truth for decades. Grateful for your clarity and for this kind of writing community.
This is so grounded and compassionate. The way you name distrust, not desire, as the real injury of purity culture feels exactly right. That internalized self-surveillance does not dissolve when belief does. It lingers in the body, in language, in sensation.
I also really appreciate how you frame pleasure not as rebellion but as regulation and repair. That shift, from proving freedom to inhabiting safety, feels like an important reorientation for people healing from high-control systems.
And the section on language hit hard. Silence as a technology of control does not get talked about enough. Reclaiming words is not edginess. It is nervous-system permission.
This piece holds nuance without flinching, humor without minimization, and depth without turning healing into a performance. Thank you for naming what so many of us felt but did not have words for yet.